# Vollständige fiktive Entscheidungen Konstruierte Übung: acht Übergabekarten, drei unklare Zuständigkeitsfelder in SRC-r2. M-DEMO, P-DEMO und DEST-DEMO sind abstrakte Referenzen; #DemoReviewRoom ist eine fiktive Vereinbarung, keine bestätigte reale Veranstaltung. Keine Konten, Beiträge, Tagsuchen oder Empfänger wurden benutzt. ## T1 — Aktuelle Vereinbarung Aktuelle Quellfassung und Tag stimmen überein; der getrennt gelieferte Prüfsummenvermerk passt zur echten lokalen r2-Datei. Das ist keine native Veröffentlichung oder geprüfte Empfängerkopie. Plan: {"case_id": "T1", "member_ref": "M-DEMO", "post_ref": "P-DEMO", "source_revision": "SRC-r2", "reviewed_revision": "r2", "export_revision": "r2", "export_ref": "post-r2", "proposed_tag": "#DemoReviewRoom", "purpose": "declared_convention", "require_destination": "yes", "intent": "copy_review", "comparison_age_hours": "168", "comparison_format": "text", "missing_policy": "retain_unknown", "result_unit": "impressions", "interpretation": "descriptive_only"} Getrennt gelieferte Beobachtung: {"case_id": "T1", "member_ref": "M-DEMO", "post_ref": "P-DEMO", "selected_sha256": {"en": "38b56348b0b7d4710b3114d8844a4a241a1fbb10f0dacc1fb74fdbff4a94c6bf", "de": "e3d8c68aadd3da8a8cc812e272bd61a616e299cbc6de6be8ba1ffa71d17bea03"}, "destination_ref": "DEST-DEMO", "destination_tag": "#DemoReviewRoom", "readback_sha256": {"en": "38b56348b0b7d4710b3114d8844a4a241a1fbb10f0dacc1fb74fdbff4a94c6bf", "de": "e3d8c68aadd3da8a8cc812e272bd61a616e299cbc6de6be8ba1ffa71d17bea03"}, "origin": "constructed_supplied", "native": false} Phasenabgleich: {"decision": "supplied_checksums_match", "phases": {"target": "declared_match", "relevance": "declared_supported", "export": "supplied_selection_matches_local_bytes", "destination": "supplied_context_match", "readback": "supplied_checksum_matches_revision", "comparison": "not_requested"}} ## T2 — Ältere Exportdatei Quelle und Prüfung beziehen sich auf r2, der gelieferte Export auf r1. Die ältere Angabe mit zwei Feldern und ihr Tag werden dadurch nicht aktuell. Plan: {"case_id": "T2", "member_ref": "M-DEMO", "post_ref": "P-DEMO", "source_revision": "SRC-r2", "reviewed_revision": "r2", "export_revision": "r1", "export_ref": "post-r1", "proposed_tag": "#DemoReviewRoom", "purpose": "declared_convention", "require_destination": "yes", "intent": "copy_review", "comparison_age_hours": "168", "comparison_format": "text", "missing_policy": "retain_unknown", "result_unit": "impressions", "interpretation": "descriptive_only"} Getrennt gelieferte Beobachtung: {"case_id": "T2", "member_ref": "M-DEMO", "post_ref": "P-DEMO", "selected_sha256": {"en": "93e9aa1600366da4691a00e2425d87d1be33e1b1308d696604a6a93c8c89fe21", "de": "48c66b0f24590724eab54801dd8f59e787fb4e4d5b4addd02337fb6a0cbac5e2"}, "destination_ref": "DEST-DEMO", "destination_tag": "#DemoReviewRoom", "readback_sha256": {"en": "93e9aa1600366da4691a00e2425d87d1be33e1b1308d696604a6a93c8c89fe21", "de": "48c66b0f24590724eab54801dd8f59e787fb4e4d5b4addd02337fb6a0cbac5e2"}, "origin": "constructed_supplied", "native": false} Phasenabgleich: {"decision": "hold_revision", "phases": {"target": "declared_match", "relevance": "declared_supported", "export": "stale_revision", "destination": "not_requested", "readback": "unresolved", "comparison": "not_requested"}} ## T3 — Sachfremder beliebter Tag Die Quelle erklärt das beliebte Etikett als sachfremd. Lass es weg; das Prüfskript hat keine Bedeutung aus dem Text erkannt. Plan: {"case_id": "T3", "member_ref": "M-DEMO", "post_ref": "P-DEMO", "source_revision": "SRC-r2", "reviewed_revision": "r2", "export_revision": "r2", "export_ref": "post-r2", "proposed_tag": "#Viral", "purpose": "popular_unrelated", "require_destination": "yes", "intent": "copy_review", "comparison_age_hours": "168", "comparison_format": "text", "missing_policy": "retain_unknown", "result_unit": "impressions", "interpretation": "descriptive_only"} Getrennt gelieferte Beobachtung: {"case_id": "T3", "member_ref": "M-DEMO", "post_ref": "P-DEMO", "selected_sha256": {"en": null, "de": null}, "destination_ref": null, "destination_tag": null, "readback_sha256": {"en": null, "de": null}, "origin": "constructed_supplied", "native": false} Phasenabgleich: {"decision": "omit_unrelated_tag", "phases": {"target": "declared_match", "relevance": "declared_unrelated", "export": "unresolved", "destination": "not_requested", "readback": "unresolved", "comparison": "not_requested"}} ## T4 — Offene Bedeutung Das gelieferte redaktionelle Urteil ist unbekannt. Eine plausible Schreibweise ersetzt keine Relevanzprüfung. Plan: {"case_id": "T4", "member_ref": "M-DEMO", "post_ref": "P-DEMO", "source_revision": "SRC-r2", "reviewed_revision": "r2", "export_revision": "r2", "export_ref": "post-r2", "proposed_tag": "#Review", "purpose": "ambiguous", "require_destination": "yes", "intent": "copy_review", "comparison_age_hours": "168", "comparison_format": "text", "missing_policy": "retain_unknown", "result_unit": "impressions", "interpretation": "descriptive_only"} Getrennt gelieferte Beobachtung: {"case_id": "T4", "member_ref": "M-DEMO", "post_ref": "P-DEMO", "selected_sha256": {"en": null, "de": null}, "destination_ref": null, "destination_tag": null, "readback_sha256": {"en": null, "de": null}, "origin": "constructed_supplied", "native": false} Phasenabgleich: {"decision": "review_meaning", "phases": {"target": "declared_match", "relevance": "unresolved", "export": "unresolved", "destination": "not_requested", "readback": "unresolved", "comparison": "not_requested"}} ## T5 — Nur erzeugtes Etikett Aktuelle lokale Bytes sind geliefert, aber Zielkontext und spätere Kopie fehlen. Das tatsächliche Ziel bleibt unbekannt. Plan: {"case_id": "T5", "member_ref": "M-DEMO", "post_ref": "P-DEMO", "source_revision": "SRC-r2", "reviewed_revision": "r2", "export_revision": "r2", "export_ref": "post-r2", "proposed_tag": "#DemoReviewRoom", "purpose": "declared_convention", "require_destination": "yes", "intent": "copy_review", "comparison_age_hours": "168", "comparison_format": "text", "missing_policy": "retain_unknown", "result_unit": "impressions", "interpretation": "descriptive_only"} Getrennt gelieferte Beobachtung: {"case_id": "T5", "member_ref": "M-DEMO", "post_ref": "P-DEMO", "selected_sha256": {"en": "38b56348b0b7d4710b3114d8844a4a241a1fbb10f0dacc1fb74fdbff4a94c6bf", "de": "e3d8c68aadd3da8a8cc812e272bd61a616e299cbc6de6be8ba1ffa71d17bea03"}, "destination_ref": null, "destination_tag": null, "readback_sha256": {"en": null, "de": null}, "origin": "constructed_supplied", "native": false} Phasenabgleich: {"decision": "destination_unknown", "phases": {"target": "declared_match", "relevance": "declared_supported", "export": "supplied_selection_matches_local_bytes", "destination": "unknown", "readback": "unknown", "comparison": "not_requested"}} ## T6 — Falsches Mitglied Der Plan zielt auf ein anderes Mitglied, die gelieferte Beobachtung auf M-DEMO. Ein plausibler Tag behebt das nicht. Plan: {"case_id": "T6", "member_ref": "M-OTHER", "post_ref": "P-DEMO", "source_revision": "SRC-r2", "reviewed_revision": "r2", "export_revision": "r2", "export_ref": "post-r2", "proposed_tag": "#DemoReviewRoom", "purpose": "declared_convention", "require_destination": "yes", "intent": "copy_review", "comparison_age_hours": "168", "comparison_format": "text", "missing_policy": "retain_unknown", "result_unit": "impressions", "interpretation": "descriptive_only"} Getrennt gelieferte Beobachtung: {"case_id": "T6", "member_ref": "M-DEMO", "post_ref": "P-DEMO", "selected_sha256": {"en": "38b56348b0b7d4710b3114d8844a4a241a1fbb10f0dacc1fb74fdbff4a94c6bf", "de": "e3d8c68aadd3da8a8cc812e272bd61a616e299cbc6de6be8ba1ffa71d17bea03"}, "destination_ref": "DEST-DEMO", "destination_tag": "#DemoReviewRoom", "readback_sha256": {"en": "38b56348b0b7d4710b3114d8844a4a241a1fbb10f0dacc1fb74fdbff4a94c6bf", "de": "e3d8c68aadd3da8a8cc812e272bd61a616e299cbc6de6be8ba1ffa71d17bea03"}, "origin": "constructed_supplied", "native": false} Phasenabgleich: {"decision": "hold_target", "phases": {"target": "mismatch", "relevance": "unresolved", "export": "unresolved", "destination": "not_requested", "readback": "unresolved", "comparison": "not_requested"}} ## T7 — Bewusst ohne Hashtag Die echte aktuelle Datei ohne Tag passt zum gelieferten Prüfsummenvermerk. Null Tags sind eine Relevanzentscheidung, kein Optimumbeleg. Plan: {"case_id": "T7", "member_ref": "M-DEMO", "post_ref": "P-DEMO", "source_revision": "SRC-r2", "reviewed_revision": "r2", "export_revision": "r2", "export_ref": "post-plain", "proposed_tag": "", "purpose": "ordinary_prose", "require_destination": "no", "intent": "copy_review", "comparison_age_hours": "168", "comparison_format": "text", "missing_policy": "retain_unknown", "result_unit": "impressions", "interpretation": "descriptive_only"} Getrennt gelieferte Beobachtung: {"case_id": "T7", "member_ref": "M-DEMO", "post_ref": "P-DEMO", "selected_sha256": {"en": "2f7684c8e5f65077bc2811e0f903ac25f1e63db6021ed1f7a6825c92fc5af157", "de": "e6bbdace6584f2f6dad38a94e58d4ec39bb3ef872a9255cdc909afb97d98ee94"}, "destination_ref": null, "destination_tag": null, "readback_sha256": {"en": "2f7684c8e5f65077bc2811e0f903ac25f1e63db6021ed1f7a6825c92fc5af157", "de": "e6bbdace6584f2f6dad38a94e58d4ec39bb3ef872a9255cdc909afb97d98ee94"}, "origin": "constructed_supplied", "native": false} Phasenabgleich: {"decision": "supplied_checksums_match", "phases": {"target": "declared_match", "relevance": "declared_supported", "export": "supplied_selection_matches_local_bytes", "destination": "not_requested", "readback": "supplied_checksum_matches_revision", "comparison": "not_requested"}} ## T8 — Nur vorbereitete Datei Aktuelle lokale Bytes existieren, Auswahl und spätere Kopie bleiben unbekannt. Keine Veröffentlichung behaupten oder unklaren Vorgang wiederholen. Plan: {"case_id": "T8", "member_ref": "M-DEMO", "post_ref": "P-DEMO", "source_revision": "SRC-r2", "reviewed_revision": "r2", "export_revision": "r2", "export_ref": "post-r2", "proposed_tag": "#DemoReviewRoom", "purpose": "declared_convention", "require_destination": "yes", "intent": "copy_review", "comparison_age_hours": "168", "comparison_format": "text", "missing_policy": "retain_unknown", "result_unit": "impressions", "interpretation": "descriptive_only"} Getrennt gelieferte Beobachtung: {"case_id": "T8", "member_ref": "M-DEMO", "post_ref": "P-DEMO", "selected_sha256": {"en": null, "de": null}, "destination_ref": "DEST-DEMO", "destination_tag": "#DemoReviewRoom", "readback_sha256": {"en": null, "de": null}, "origin": "constructed_supplied", "native": false} Phasenabgleich: {"decision": "prepared_readback_unknown", "phases": {"target": "declared_match", "relevance": "declared_supported", "export": "prepared_selection_unknown", "destination": "supplied_context_match", "readback": "unknown", "comparison": "not_requested"}} ## T9 — Geändertes Vergleichsalter 24 Stunden widersprechen dem festgelegten 168-Stunden-Vergleich. X1 bleibt erhalten, aber ausgeschlossen; seine 900 sind kein vergleichbarer Sieger. Plan: {"case_id": "T9", "member_ref": "M-DEMO", "post_ref": "P-DEMO", "source_revision": "SRC-r2", "reviewed_revision": "r2", "export_revision": "r2", "export_ref": "post-r2", "proposed_tag": "#DemoReviewRoom", "purpose": "declared_convention", "require_destination": "yes", "intent": "compare", "comparison_age_hours": "24", "comparison_format": "text", "missing_policy": "retain_unknown", "result_unit": "impressions", "interpretation": "descriptive_only"} Getrennt gelieferte Beobachtung: {"case_id": "T9", "member_ref": "M-DEMO", "post_ref": "P-DEMO", "selected_sha256": {"en": "38b56348b0b7d4710b3114d8844a4a241a1fbb10f0dacc1fb74fdbff4a94c6bf", "de": "e3d8c68aadd3da8a8cc812e272bd61a616e299cbc6de6be8ba1ffa71d17bea03"}, "destination_ref": "DEST-DEMO", "destination_tag": "#DemoReviewRoom", "readback_sha256": {"en": "38b56348b0b7d4710b3114d8844a4a241a1fbb10f0dacc1fb74fdbff4a94c6bf", "de": "e3d8c68aadd3da8a8cc812e272bd61a616e299cbc6de6be8ba1ffa71d17bea03"}, "origin": "constructed_supplied", "native": false} Phasenabgleich: {"decision": "hold_comparison_scope", "phases": {"target": "declared_match", "relevance": "declared_supported", "export": "supplied_selection_matches_local_bytes", "destination": "supplied_context_match", "readback": "supplied_checksum_matches_revision", "comparison": "protocol_mismatch"}} ## T10 — Erfundene fehlende Zahl Für H4 fehlen gelieferte Impressionen. Das bleibt unbekannt; Likes oder Antworten füllen es nicht. Plan: {"case_id": "T10", "member_ref": "M-DEMO", "post_ref": "P-DEMO", "source_revision": "SRC-r2", "reviewed_revision": "r2", "export_revision": "r2", "export_ref": "post-r2", "proposed_tag": "#DemoReviewRoom", "purpose": "declared_convention", "require_destination": "yes", "intent": "compare", "comparison_age_hours": "168", "comparison_format": "text", "missing_policy": "reconstruct_from_likes", "result_unit": "impressions", "interpretation": "descriptive_only"} Getrennt gelieferte Beobachtung: {"case_id": "T10", "member_ref": "M-DEMO", "post_ref": "P-DEMO", "selected_sha256": {"en": "38b56348b0b7d4710b3114d8844a4a241a1fbb10f0dacc1fb74fdbff4a94c6bf", "de": "e3d8c68aadd3da8a8cc812e272bd61a616e299cbc6de6be8ba1ffa71d17bea03"}, "destination_ref": "DEST-DEMO", "destination_tag": "#DemoReviewRoom", "readback_sha256": {"en": "38b56348b0b7d4710b3114d8844a4a241a1fbb10f0dacc1fb74fdbff4a94c6bf", "de": "e3d8c68aadd3da8a8cc812e272bd61a616e299cbc6de6be8ba1ffa71d17bea03"}, "origin": "constructed_supplied", "native": false} Phasenabgleich: {"decision": "keep_missing_unknown", "phases": {"target": "declared_match", "relevance": "declared_supported", "export": "supplied_selection_matches_local_bytes", "destination": "supplied_context_match", "readback": "supplied_checksum_matches_revision", "comparison": "unsupported_imputation"}} ## T11 — Falsche Kennzahleinheit Gelieferte Impressionen zählen Ausspielungen, keine eindeutigen Personen. Einheiten und Nenner bleiben erhalten. Plan: {"case_id": "T11", "member_ref": "M-DEMO", "post_ref": "P-DEMO", "source_revision": "SRC-r2", "reviewed_revision": "r2", "export_revision": "r2", "export_ref": "post-r2", "proposed_tag": "#DemoReviewRoom", "purpose": "declared_convention", "require_destination": "yes", "intent": "compare", "comparison_age_hours": "168", "comparison_format": "text", "missing_policy": "retain_unknown", "result_unit": "unique_people", "interpretation": "descriptive_only"} Getrennt gelieferte Beobachtung: {"case_id": "T11", "member_ref": "M-DEMO", "post_ref": "P-DEMO", "selected_sha256": {"en": "38b56348b0b7d4710b3114d8844a4a241a1fbb10f0dacc1fb74fdbff4a94c6bf", "de": "e3d8c68aadd3da8a8cc812e272bd61a616e299cbc6de6be8ba1ffa71d17bea03"}, "destination_ref": "DEST-DEMO", "destination_tag": "#DemoReviewRoom", "readback_sha256": {"en": "38b56348b0b7d4710b3114d8844a4a241a1fbb10f0dacc1fb74fdbff4a94c6bf", "de": "e3d8c68aadd3da8a8cc812e272bd61a616e299cbc6de6be8ba1ffa71d17bea03"}, "origin": "constructed_supplied", "native": false} Phasenabgleich: {"decision": "keep_metric_units", "phases": {"target": "declared_match", "relevance": "declared_supported", "export": "supplied_selection_matches_local_bytes", "destination": "supplied_context_match", "readback": "supplied_checksum_matches_revision", "comparison": "unit_mismatch"}} ## T12 — Begrenzte Beschreibung Alle acht registrierten Zeilen, sieben geeignete Fälle und der fehlende H4-Wert bleiben. Nur verfügbare Mediane beschreiben, keinen Ursache- oder Kaufbeleg. Plan: {"case_id": "T12", "member_ref": "M-DEMO", "post_ref": "P-DEMO", "source_revision": "SRC-r2", "reviewed_revision": "r2", "export_revision": "r2", "export_ref": "post-r2", "proposed_tag": "#DemoReviewRoom", "purpose": "declared_convention", "require_destination": "yes", "intent": "compare", "comparison_age_hours": "168", "comparison_format": "text", "missing_policy": "retain_unknown", "result_unit": "impressions", "interpretation": "descriptive_only"} Getrennt gelieferte Beobachtung: {"case_id": "T12", "member_ref": "M-DEMO", "post_ref": "P-DEMO", "selected_sha256": {"en": "38b56348b0b7d4710b3114d8844a4a241a1fbb10f0dacc1fb74fdbff4a94c6bf", "de": "e3d8c68aadd3da8a8cc812e272bd61a616e299cbc6de6be8ba1ffa71d17bea03"}, "destination_ref": "DEST-DEMO", "destination_tag": "#DemoReviewRoom", "readback_sha256": {"en": "38b56348b0b7d4710b3114d8844a4a241a1fbb10f0dacc1fb74fdbff4a94c6bf", "de": "e3d8c68aadd3da8a8cc812e272bd61a616e299cbc6de6be8ba1ffa71d17bea03"}, "origin": "constructed_supplied", "native": false} Phasenabgleich: {"decision": "describe_with_denominators", "phases": {"target": "declared_match", "relevance": "declared_supported", "export": "supplied_selection_matches_local_bytes", "destination": "supplied_context_match", "readback": "supplied_checksum_matches_revision", "comparison": "bounded_supplied_descriptive_only"}} ## Begrenzte Rechnung { "registered_rows": 8, "eligible_rows": 7, "excluded_ids": [ "X1" ], "groups": { "none": { "eligible_posts": 3, "impressions_available": 3, "impressions_missing": 0, "median_available_impressions": 140, "qualified_replies_available": 3, "median_available_qualified_replies": 1 }, "one": { "eligible_posts": 4, "impressions_available": 3, "impressions_missing": 1, "median_available_impressions": 160, "qualified_replies_available": 4, "median_available_qualified_replies": 0.5 } }, "interpretation": "Fictional descriptive calculations on supplied nonrandom rows; no causal hashtag effect, reader preference, unique audience or buying intent." } Ohne Tag: drei geeignete Beiträge, 3/3 Impressionswerte, Median 140. Mit einem Tag: vier geeignete Beiträge, 3/4 Impressionswerte, ein fehlender Wert, Median der drei verfügbaren Werte 160. Antworten: Mediane 1 und 0,5; alle drei Antwortwerte ohne Tag und alle vier mit Tag liegen vor. Der 24-Stunden-Fall X1 ist ausgeschlossen, bleibt aber gespeichert. Ohne den niedrigen H1-Wert würde der verfügbare Median 230 statt 160 lauten; das ist eine Auswahlverzerrung im Beispiel. Keine optimale Tagzahl, keine Ursache und kein echter Lesertest.