# Complete fictional decisions

Constructed exercise: eight handover cards, three unclear owner fields in SRC-r2. M-DEMO, P-DEMO and DEST-DEMO are abstract references; #DemoReviewRoom is a fictional convention, not a verified real event. No account, post, tag search or recipient was used.

## T1 — Current convention

The declared current revision and tag agree; the separately supplied checksum matches the actual local r2 file. This is not a native publication or an inspected recipient copy.

Plan: {"case_id": "T1", "member_ref": "M-DEMO", "post_ref": "P-DEMO", "source_revision": "SRC-r2", "reviewed_revision": "r2", "export_revision": "r2", "export_ref": "post-r2", "proposed_tag": "#DemoReviewRoom", "purpose": "declared_convention", "require_destination": "yes", "intent": "copy_review", "comparison_age_hours": "168", "comparison_format": "text", "missing_policy": "retain_unknown", "result_unit": "impressions", "interpretation": "descriptive_only"}

Separately supplied observation: {"case_id": "T1", "member_ref": "M-DEMO", "post_ref": "P-DEMO", "selected_sha256": {"en": "38b56348b0b7d4710b3114d8844a4a241a1fbb10f0dacc1fb74fdbff4a94c6bf", "de": "e3d8c68aadd3da8a8cc812e272bd61a616e299cbc6de6be8ba1ffa71d17bea03"}, "destination_ref": "DEST-DEMO", "destination_tag": "#DemoReviewRoom", "readback_sha256": {"en": "38b56348b0b7d4710b3114d8844a4a241a1fbb10f0dacc1fb74fdbff4a94c6bf", "de": "e3d8c68aadd3da8a8cc812e272bd61a616e299cbc6de6be8ba1ffa71d17bea03"}, "origin": "constructed_supplied", "native": false}

Phase results: {"decision": "supplied_checksums_match", "phases": {"target": "declared_match", "relevance": "declared_supported", "export": "supplied_selection_matches_local_bytes", "destination": "supplied_context_match", "readback": "supplied_checksum_matches_revision", "comparison": "not_requested"}}

## T2 — Older exported file

The source/review is current r2, but the supplied export is r1. Keep the older two-field count/tag separate; do not relabel it current.

Plan: {"case_id": "T2", "member_ref": "M-DEMO", "post_ref": "P-DEMO", "source_revision": "SRC-r2", "reviewed_revision": "r2", "export_revision": "r1", "export_ref": "post-r1", "proposed_tag": "#DemoReviewRoom", "purpose": "declared_convention", "require_destination": "yes", "intent": "copy_review", "comparison_age_hours": "168", "comparison_format": "text", "missing_policy": "retain_unknown", "result_unit": "impressions", "interpretation": "descriptive_only"}

Separately supplied observation: {"case_id": "T2", "member_ref": "M-DEMO", "post_ref": "P-DEMO", "selected_sha256": {"en": "93e9aa1600366da4691a00e2425d87d1be33e1b1308d696604a6a93c8c89fe21", "de": "48c66b0f24590724eab54801dd8f59e787fb4e4d5b4addd02337fb6a0cbac5e2"}, "destination_ref": "DEST-DEMO", "destination_tag": "#DemoReviewRoom", "readback_sha256": {"en": "93e9aa1600366da4691a00e2425d87d1be33e1b1308d696604a6a93c8c89fe21", "de": "48c66b0f24590724eab54801dd8f59e787fb4e4d5b4addd02337fb6a0cbac5e2"}, "origin": "constructed_supplied", "native": false}

Phase results: {"decision": "hold_revision", "phases": {"target": "declared_match", "relevance": "declared_supported", "export": "stale_revision", "destination": "not_requested", "readback": "unresolved", "comparison": "not_requested"}}

## T3 — Unrelated popular tag

The source declares this popular label unrelated. Omit it; the checker did not infer meaning from prose.

Plan: {"case_id": "T3", "member_ref": "M-DEMO", "post_ref": "P-DEMO", "source_revision": "SRC-r2", "reviewed_revision": "r2", "export_revision": "r2", "export_ref": "post-r2", "proposed_tag": "#Viral", "purpose": "popular_unrelated", "require_destination": "yes", "intent": "copy_review", "comparison_age_hours": "168", "comparison_format": "text", "missing_policy": "retain_unknown", "result_unit": "impressions", "interpretation": "descriptive_only"}

Separately supplied observation: {"case_id": "T3", "member_ref": "M-DEMO", "post_ref": "P-DEMO", "selected_sha256": {"en": null, "de": null}, "destination_ref": null, "destination_tag": null, "readback_sha256": {"en": null, "de": null}, "origin": "constructed_supplied", "native": false}

Phase results: {"decision": "omit_unrelated_tag", "phases": {"target": "declared_match", "relevance": "declared_unrelated", "export": "unresolved", "destination": "not_requested", "readback": "unresolved", "comparison": "not_requested"}}

## T4 — Unresolved meaning

The declared judgment is unknown. A plausible spelling does not complete a relevance review.

Plan: {"case_id": "T4", "member_ref": "M-DEMO", "post_ref": "P-DEMO", "source_revision": "SRC-r2", "reviewed_revision": "r2", "export_revision": "r2", "export_ref": "post-r2", "proposed_tag": "#Review", "purpose": "ambiguous", "require_destination": "yes", "intent": "copy_review", "comparison_age_hours": "168", "comparison_format": "text", "missing_policy": "retain_unknown", "result_unit": "impressions", "interpretation": "descriptive_only"}

Separately supplied observation: {"case_id": "T4", "member_ref": "M-DEMO", "post_ref": "P-DEMO", "selected_sha256": {"en": null, "de": null}, "destination_ref": null, "destination_tag": null, "readback_sha256": {"en": null, "de": null}, "origin": "constructed_supplied", "native": false}

Phase results: {"decision": "review_meaning", "phases": {"target": "declared_match", "relevance": "unresolved", "export": "unresolved", "destination": "not_requested", "readback": "unresolved", "comparison": "not_requested"}}

## T5 — Generated label only

Current local bytes are supplied, but no destination context/readback is supplied. Keep that destination unknown.

Plan: {"case_id": "T5", "member_ref": "M-DEMO", "post_ref": "P-DEMO", "source_revision": "SRC-r2", "reviewed_revision": "r2", "export_revision": "r2", "export_ref": "post-r2", "proposed_tag": "#DemoReviewRoom", "purpose": "declared_convention", "require_destination": "yes", "intent": "copy_review", "comparison_age_hours": "168", "comparison_format": "text", "missing_policy": "retain_unknown", "result_unit": "impressions", "interpretation": "descriptive_only"}

Separately supplied observation: {"case_id": "T5", "member_ref": "M-DEMO", "post_ref": "P-DEMO", "selected_sha256": {"en": "38b56348b0b7d4710b3114d8844a4a241a1fbb10f0dacc1fb74fdbff4a94c6bf", "de": "e3d8c68aadd3da8a8cc812e272bd61a616e299cbc6de6be8ba1ffa71d17bea03"}, "destination_ref": null, "destination_tag": null, "readback_sha256": {"en": null, "de": null}, "origin": "constructed_supplied", "native": false}

Phase results: {"decision": "destination_unknown", "phases": {"target": "declared_match", "relevance": "declared_supported", "export": "supplied_selection_matches_local_bytes", "destination": "unknown", "readback": "unknown", "comparison": "not_requested"}}

## T6 — Wrong member

The plan targets another member while the supplied record concerns M-DEMO. A correct-looking tag does not fix that mismatch.

Plan: {"case_id": "T6", "member_ref": "M-OTHER", "post_ref": "P-DEMO", "source_revision": "SRC-r2", "reviewed_revision": "r2", "export_revision": "r2", "export_ref": "post-r2", "proposed_tag": "#DemoReviewRoom", "purpose": "declared_convention", "require_destination": "yes", "intent": "copy_review", "comparison_age_hours": "168", "comparison_format": "text", "missing_policy": "retain_unknown", "result_unit": "impressions", "interpretation": "descriptive_only"}

Separately supplied observation: {"case_id": "T6", "member_ref": "M-DEMO", "post_ref": "P-DEMO", "selected_sha256": {"en": "38b56348b0b7d4710b3114d8844a4a241a1fbb10f0dacc1fb74fdbff4a94c6bf", "de": "e3d8c68aadd3da8a8cc812e272bd61a616e299cbc6de6be8ba1ffa71d17bea03"}, "destination_ref": "DEST-DEMO", "destination_tag": "#DemoReviewRoom", "readback_sha256": {"en": "38b56348b0b7d4710b3114d8844a4a241a1fbb10f0dacc1fb74fdbff4a94c6bf", "de": "e3d8c68aadd3da8a8cc812e272bd61a616e299cbc6de6be8ba1ffa71d17bea03"}, "origin": "constructed_supplied", "native": false}

Phase results: {"decision": "hold_target", "phases": {"target": "mismatch", "relevance": "unresolved", "export": "unresolved", "destination": "not_requested", "readback": "unresolved", "comparison": "not_requested"}}

## T7 — Deliberately no hashtag

The actual current untagged file matches the supplied checksum declaration. Zero tags is a relevance choice, not proof of an optimum.

Plan: {"case_id": "T7", "member_ref": "M-DEMO", "post_ref": "P-DEMO", "source_revision": "SRC-r2", "reviewed_revision": "r2", "export_revision": "r2", "export_ref": "post-plain", "proposed_tag": "", "purpose": "ordinary_prose", "require_destination": "no", "intent": "copy_review", "comparison_age_hours": "168", "comparison_format": "text", "missing_policy": "retain_unknown", "result_unit": "impressions", "interpretation": "descriptive_only"}

Separately supplied observation: {"case_id": "T7", "member_ref": "M-DEMO", "post_ref": "P-DEMO", "selected_sha256": {"en": "2f7684c8e5f65077bc2811e0f903ac25f1e63db6021ed1f7a6825c92fc5af157", "de": "e6bbdace6584f2f6dad38a94e58d4ec39bb3ef872a9255cdc909afb97d98ee94"}, "destination_ref": null, "destination_tag": null, "readback_sha256": {"en": "2f7684c8e5f65077bc2811e0f903ac25f1e63db6021ed1f7a6825c92fc5af157", "de": "e6bbdace6584f2f6dad38a94e58d4ec39bb3ef872a9255cdc909afb97d98ee94"}, "origin": "constructed_supplied", "native": false}

Phase results: {"decision": "supplied_checksums_match", "phases": {"target": "declared_match", "relevance": "declared_supported", "export": "supplied_selection_matches_local_bytes", "destination": "not_requested", "readback": "supplied_checksum_matches_revision", "comparison": "not_requested"}}

## T8 — Prepared file only

Current local bytes exist, but selection and later copy remain unknown. Do not report or replay a publication.

Plan: {"case_id": "T8", "member_ref": "M-DEMO", "post_ref": "P-DEMO", "source_revision": "SRC-r2", "reviewed_revision": "r2", "export_revision": "r2", "export_ref": "post-r2", "proposed_tag": "#DemoReviewRoom", "purpose": "declared_convention", "require_destination": "yes", "intent": "copy_review", "comparison_age_hours": "168", "comparison_format": "text", "missing_policy": "retain_unknown", "result_unit": "impressions", "interpretation": "descriptive_only"}

Separately supplied observation: {"case_id": "T8", "member_ref": "M-DEMO", "post_ref": "P-DEMO", "selected_sha256": {"en": null, "de": null}, "destination_ref": "DEST-DEMO", "destination_tag": "#DemoReviewRoom", "readback_sha256": {"en": null, "de": null}, "origin": "constructed_supplied", "native": false}

Phase results: {"decision": "prepared_readback_unknown", "phases": {"target": "declared_match", "relevance": "declared_supported", "export": "prepared_selection_unknown", "destination": "supplied_context_match", "readback": "unknown", "comparison": "not_requested"}}

## T9 — Changed comparison age

24 hours conflicts with the declared 168-hour comparison. X1 remains retained but excluded; its 900 is not a comparable winner.

Plan: {"case_id": "T9", "member_ref": "M-DEMO", "post_ref": "P-DEMO", "source_revision": "SRC-r2", "reviewed_revision": "r2", "export_revision": "r2", "export_ref": "post-r2", "proposed_tag": "#DemoReviewRoom", "purpose": "declared_convention", "require_destination": "yes", "intent": "compare", "comparison_age_hours": "24", "comparison_format": "text", "missing_policy": "retain_unknown", "result_unit": "impressions", "interpretation": "descriptive_only"}

Separately supplied observation: {"case_id": "T9", "member_ref": "M-DEMO", "post_ref": "P-DEMO", "selected_sha256": {"en": "38b56348b0b7d4710b3114d8844a4a241a1fbb10f0dacc1fb74fdbff4a94c6bf", "de": "e3d8c68aadd3da8a8cc812e272bd61a616e299cbc6de6be8ba1ffa71d17bea03"}, "destination_ref": "DEST-DEMO", "destination_tag": "#DemoReviewRoom", "readback_sha256": {"en": "38b56348b0b7d4710b3114d8844a4a241a1fbb10f0dacc1fb74fdbff4a94c6bf", "de": "e3d8c68aadd3da8a8cc812e272bd61a616e299cbc6de6be8ba1ffa71d17bea03"}, "origin": "constructed_supplied", "native": false}

Phase results: {"decision": "hold_comparison_scope", "phases": {"target": "declared_match", "relevance": "declared_supported", "export": "supplied_selection_matches_local_bytes", "destination": "supplied_context_match", "readback": "supplied_checksum_matches_revision", "comparison": "protocol_mismatch"}}

## T10 — Reconstructed missing count

H4 has no supplied impression count. Preserve it as missing; likes/replies cannot fill it.

Plan: {"case_id": "T10", "member_ref": "M-DEMO", "post_ref": "P-DEMO", "source_revision": "SRC-r2", "reviewed_revision": "r2", "export_revision": "r2", "export_ref": "post-r2", "proposed_tag": "#DemoReviewRoom", "purpose": "declared_convention", "require_destination": "yes", "intent": "compare", "comparison_age_hours": "168", "comparison_format": "text", "missing_policy": "reconstruct_from_likes", "result_unit": "impressions", "interpretation": "descriptive_only"}

Separately supplied observation: {"case_id": "T10", "member_ref": "M-DEMO", "post_ref": "P-DEMO", "selected_sha256": {"en": "38b56348b0b7d4710b3114d8844a4a241a1fbb10f0dacc1fb74fdbff4a94c6bf", "de": "e3d8c68aadd3da8a8cc812e272bd61a616e299cbc6de6be8ba1ffa71d17bea03"}, "destination_ref": "DEST-DEMO", "destination_tag": "#DemoReviewRoom", "readback_sha256": {"en": "38b56348b0b7d4710b3114d8844a4a241a1fbb10f0dacc1fb74fdbff4a94c6bf", "de": "e3d8c68aadd3da8a8cc812e272bd61a616e299cbc6de6be8ba1ffa71d17bea03"}, "origin": "constructed_supplied", "native": false}

Phase results: {"decision": "keep_missing_unknown", "phases": {"target": "declared_match", "relevance": "declared_supported", "export": "supplied_selection_matches_local_bytes", "destination": "supplied_context_match", "readback": "supplied_checksum_matches_revision", "comparison": "unsupported_imputation"}}

## T11 — Wrong metric unit

Supplied impressions count displays, not unique people. Keep the original units and denominators.

Plan: {"case_id": "T11", "member_ref": "M-DEMO", "post_ref": "P-DEMO", "source_revision": "SRC-r2", "reviewed_revision": "r2", "export_revision": "r2", "export_ref": "post-r2", "proposed_tag": "#DemoReviewRoom", "purpose": "declared_convention", "require_destination": "yes", "intent": "compare", "comparison_age_hours": "168", "comparison_format": "text", "missing_policy": "retain_unknown", "result_unit": "unique_people", "interpretation": "descriptive_only"}

Separately supplied observation: {"case_id": "T11", "member_ref": "M-DEMO", "post_ref": "P-DEMO", "selected_sha256": {"en": "38b56348b0b7d4710b3114d8844a4a241a1fbb10f0dacc1fb74fdbff4a94c6bf", "de": "e3d8c68aadd3da8a8cc812e272bd61a616e299cbc6de6be8ba1ffa71d17bea03"}, "destination_ref": "DEST-DEMO", "destination_tag": "#DemoReviewRoom", "readback_sha256": {"en": "38b56348b0b7d4710b3114d8844a4a241a1fbb10f0dacc1fb74fdbff4a94c6bf", "de": "e3d8c68aadd3da8a8cc812e272bd61a616e299cbc6de6be8ba1ffa71d17bea03"}, "origin": "constructed_supplied", "native": false}

Phase results: {"decision": "keep_metric_units", "phases": {"target": "declared_match", "relevance": "declared_supported", "export": "supplied_selection_matches_local_bytes", "destination": "supplied_context_match", "readback": "supplied_checksum_matches_revision", "comparison": "unit_mismatch"}}

## T12 — Bounded description

Keep all eight registered rows, seven eligible, and the missing H4 value. Describe available medians only; no causal or buying claim.

Plan: {"case_id": "T12", "member_ref": "M-DEMO", "post_ref": "P-DEMO", "source_revision": "SRC-r2", "reviewed_revision": "r2", "export_revision": "r2", "export_ref": "post-r2", "proposed_tag": "#DemoReviewRoom", "purpose": "declared_convention", "require_destination": "yes", "intent": "compare", "comparison_age_hours": "168", "comparison_format": "text", "missing_policy": "retain_unknown", "result_unit": "impressions", "interpretation": "descriptive_only"}

Separately supplied observation: {"case_id": "T12", "member_ref": "M-DEMO", "post_ref": "P-DEMO", "selected_sha256": {"en": "38b56348b0b7d4710b3114d8844a4a241a1fbb10f0dacc1fb74fdbff4a94c6bf", "de": "e3d8c68aadd3da8a8cc812e272bd61a616e299cbc6de6be8ba1ffa71d17bea03"}, "destination_ref": "DEST-DEMO", "destination_tag": "#DemoReviewRoom", "readback_sha256": {"en": "38b56348b0b7d4710b3114d8844a4a241a1fbb10f0dacc1fb74fdbff4a94c6bf", "de": "e3d8c68aadd3da8a8cc812e272bd61a616e299cbc6de6be8ba1ffa71d17bea03"}, "origin": "constructed_supplied", "native": false}

Phase results: {"decision": "describe_with_denominators", "phases": {"target": "declared_match", "relevance": "declared_supported", "export": "supplied_selection_matches_local_bytes", "destination": "supplied_context_match", "readback": "supplied_checksum_matches_revision", "comparison": "bounded_supplied_descriptive_only"}}

## Bounded calculation

{
  "registered_rows": 8,
  "eligible_rows": 7,
  "excluded_ids": [
    "X1"
  ],
  "groups": {
    "none": {
      "eligible_posts": 3,
      "impressions_available": 3,
      "impressions_missing": 0,
      "median_available_impressions": 140,
      "qualified_replies_available": 3,
      "median_available_qualified_replies": 1
    },
    "one": {
      "eligible_posts": 4,
      "impressions_available": 3,
      "impressions_missing": 1,
      "median_available_impressions": 160,
      "qualified_replies_available": 4,
      "median_available_qualified_replies": 0.5
    }
  },
  "interpretation": "Fictional descriptive calculations on supplied nonrandom rows; no causal hashtag effect, reader preference, unique audience or buying intent."
}

No tag: three eligible posts, 3/3 impression values, median 140. One tag: four eligible posts, 3/4 impression values, one missing, median of the three available values 160. Replies: medians 1 and 0.5; all three no-tag and all four one-tag reply counts are supplied. The 24-hour X1 row is excluded but retained. Omitting the low H1 row would change the available median to 230 instead of 160; that is selection bias in this example. No optimal tag count, causal effect or real reader test.